Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Famous Forgery Cases


Early in 1972 a Federal Grand Jury heard the testimony of a Questioned Document Examiner from the Crime Laboratory of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service regarding questioned documents allegedly written by Howard R. Hughes. In these documents permission was granted for a biography of Mr. Hughes to be written by Clifford Irving. Mr. Irving had used these questioned documents to convince the editors of McGraw-Hill Book Co. and Life Magazine that he had a deal with Mr. Hughes - an allegation hotly contested by Howard Hughes when he learned of it.

The testimony of the experts from the Postal Inspection Service was that the questioned documents were not written by Mr. Hughes. Often in forgery cases it is possible to conclude that the alleged author of a document did not do the writing, but it is more difficult to conclude that a particular person did do it. This is because the writing habits of the forger will often be buried in the attempt to simulate the pictoral look and style of the "target" writing. However, in this case, there was a large amount of writing in question. Mr. Irving had even had "Mr. Hughes" write a letter to the editors of Mc-Graw Hill to validate his agreement with Mr. Irving. The volume of questioned writing was enough that Mr. Irving was not able to keep up his "disguise" and his own individual writing characteristics showed through the veneer of the simulated "Hughes" writing.
Through forensic people saw how Mr. Irving’s handwriting had slight differences from his handwriting and Mr. Hughes so they found that what was wrote was forgery.
Citation: http://qdewill.com/oldsite/famous_cases.htm

How would you tell that the handwriting is forgery?

Authentic signatures are included on such papers as checks, employment records, legal agreements, licenses, titles, wills, and any other type of personal or business transaction or agreement. Even slight handwriting alternations are considered as much a crime as the complete fabrication of a signature when the intent it to deceive.
 In both cases, tracing and freehand, the forger is unable to exactly reproduce the various impressions and downward pressures used by the original writer.
Which Forgery do you find easier? Freehand or Trace
I believe it would be freehand because you could try to practice that persons handwriting until you got it perfect and use that persons signature.

Citation: http://www.enotes.com/handwriting-forgery-reference/handwriting-forgery

Handwriting Characteristics

Skill level- can best be described as an appreciation of beauty as applied to handwriting.
Slant- refers to the angle of inclination of writing or a letter of writing from the base line of that writing. It may be forward and leaning to the right, or "backhand" if it leans to the left.
 Form- is the pictorial representation of a letter or writing movement. A highly visible dissimilarity in the form of the same letter found in both the questioned and standard material is an inherent difference in handwriting.
Movement-This is the manner in which the pen moves in order to form a letter.
Proportion- generally refers to the symmetry of an individual letter.
Height ratios- are a comparison or correlation of the height of one letter or letter segment to another letter, usually within the same word or signature.
A portion of writing as small and as innocuous as an "i" dot may at times become a prominent identifying characteristic.
"T" crossings occupy much the same weight, or more, for the document examiner as the "i" dot does. A "t" crossing may go from right to left, left to right, it may incline up, incline down, or be perfectly horizontal.
Loops- found in a cursively written letter may be symmetrical or may be flat on one side and therefore be asymmetrical.
This concept is the study of changing width of a line as pen pressure varies.
Alignment To Baseline-This is simply the relationship of the questioned writing to a baseline.  It is the adherence of the writing to either a preformed (printed) or imaginary baseline.
Pen Lift- Here we note where the writing implement lifts from the paper, usually interior to a word or signature.
Pen speed is often an essential element of the examination process. As will be discussed elsewhere, fast, fluid pen movement is difficult to duplicate by a forger.
Citation: http://www.questioneddocuments.com/Individual%20Characteristics/individual_characteristics.htm

History of Handwriting Analysis


  1.     .  Prospero Aldorisio's [25] 1611 manuscript is the first book to describe how to analyze handwriting. The major contender is Camilo Baldi's manuscript [26] which was unofficially published in 1622. The 1625 edition was probably the first authorized edition of Baldi's book.
  2.      . Alfred Binet was convinced to do research into graphology from 1893 to 1907. He ended up calling it "The science of the future", despite graphologists' rejecting the results of his research.
  3.       .In 1929 Milton Bunker founded The American Grapho Analysis Society teaching Graphoanalysis. This organization and its system split the American graphology world in two. Students had to choose between Grapho analysis or Holistic Graphology. 
  4.     .  In 1972 talks between the American Handwriting Analysis Foundation and the American Association of Handwriting Analysis started, with the aim to form a single organization. Those talks resulted in the creation of the Council of Graphological Societiesin 1976.

Famous Cases dealing with Hair/Fibers

  1. The Atlanta Child Murders- young girls had been raped and strangled with unique orange fibers on their body. A older women was abducted one day and escaped. When cops checked this man’s van had the same orange fibers as on the bodies. The forensics later found out 74 yards of this fiber had been shipped to the Ohio area and later Robert Anthony Buell was convicted.

Citation: http://www.trutv.com/library/crime/serial_killers/predators/williams/33.h
 Atlanta Child Murders- From October 1979 to May 1981, Wayne Williams killed twenty-seven young black boys in Atlanta.  As most serial killers are white, it was thought that the Atlanta child murderer was a white racist.  Most of the boys were taken from black neighborhoods where a white man would stand out, so police announced that they were looking for a probable black serial killer.
On 22 May 1981, police heard someone dumping something in the Chattahoochee river.  A black man, 22-year-old Wayne Williams, was found climbing into a station wagon, and was questioned by police then allowed to go.
When a body turned up in the river a week later police talked to Williams again.  Fibers found onthe victim matched one's found in William's car and he was arrested.  At trial Williams was found guilty and sentenced to life imprisonment.
williams.jpg (8548 bytes)



How do scientists analyze hair/fiber data?


1.By identifying and comparing animal and human hairs under a microscope, investigators gain valuable insight into events that occurred at a crime scene.
2.They can establish physical contact between suspect, victim and crime scene and use the information in court to aid in the prosecution or defense by using the information they find.
3. DNA technology has become as important in the field of hair analysis.
4. “by combining DNA testing with microscope procedures, investigators can now screen for illegal drugs, test for presence of heavy metals, test for nutritional deficiencies and discover the approximate age of a person all by analyzing a single strand of hair.”
Reliability of hair/fiber crime scene data
Even with the smallest piece of hair you could solve some of the most important parts of

a crime. If it has DNA on it or any other piece of fiber or materials this could help cases

to a extent of solving it. Or certain fibers that are not in a certain region that could

pinpoint a certain area of interest.
Citations: http://www.ehow.com/about_6102496_forensic-science_-hair-fiber-analysis.html

Hair/Fiber collecting techniques


  • Hair- Recover all hair present. If possible, use the fingers or tweezers to pick up hair, place in paper bindles or coin envelopes which should then be folded and sealed in larger envelopes. Label the outer sealed envelope.
  • If hair is attached, such as in dry blood, or caught in metal or a crack of glass, do not attempt to remove it but rather leave hair intact on the object. If the object is small, mark it, wrap it, and seal it in an envelope. If the object is large, wrap the area containing the hair in paper to prevent loss of hairs during shipment.
  • Fibers- If threads or large fibers are found, they can often be picked up with the fingers and placed in a paper bindle, then in a coin envelope, which can be sealed and marked. Never place loose fibers directly into a mailing envelope since they can be lost from this type of envelope.
  • If the fibers are short or few in number, and if it is possible to do so, wrap the area or the entire item containing the fibers in paper and send the whole exhibit to the Laboratory.
  • Pick up fibers on tape only if the laboratory in your jurisdiction allows it and gives you its requirements. When fibers or threads are recovered, always send all clothing of persons from which they might have originated to the Laboratory for comparison purposes.
Citations:http://www.crime-scene-investigator.net/collect.html